Who Is Liable in a Negligent Security Case: Owner, Property Manager, or Security Company?

negligent-security-liability

In a Tennessee negligent security case, liability can fall on the property owner, the property management company, the security company, or several of them at once, depending on who controlled the premises and who was responsible for keeping people safe. The person who attacked you is also at fault, but that does not let the businesses that ignored a known danger off the hook.

Sorting out who did what is often the hardest part of these cases. Here is how responsibility typically breaks down.

Who Can Be Held Liable for Negligent Security in Tennessee?

More than one company usually has a hand in how a property is secured. Potentially responsible parties include:

  • The property owner, which often holds title through a separate LLC
  • The property management company that runs daily operations
  • A tenant business, such as a bar, store, or club that controls its own space
  • The security contractor hired to patrol or guard the property
  • Individual security guards whose own conduct caused harm
  • Maintenance or lighting contractors responsible for locks, gates, cameras, or lights
  • A franchisor, in some cases, when it controls security standards at a franchised location

Your lawyer’s job is to trace who made the decisions that left you exposed.

When Is the Property Owner Responsible for a Criminal Attack?

The starting point in Tennessee is McClung v. Delta Square Limited Partnership, 937 S.W.2d 891 (Tenn. 1996). The Tennessee Supreme Court held that a business owes a duty to take reasonable steps against criminal acts when the foreseeable probability and gravity of harm outweigh the burden of prevention. Prior incidents on or near the property weigh heavily in that analysis.

Owners often cannot avoid that duty by handing the property to a management company. An owner who sets the budget, approves or denies security spending, or knows about repeated crimes can share responsibility for decisions that left the property unsafe.

Can You Sue a Property Management Company for Negligent Security?

Often, yes. Management companies typically control the daily decisions that matter most in these cases, including:

  • Repairing broken gates, door locks, and lighting
  • Responding to tenant and customer complaints about crime
  • Deciding whether to hire, cut, or change security services
  • Keeping incident reports and police call records

The management agreement between the owner and the manager can show which company held each responsibility. Those agreements are usually obtained through the lawsuit itself, which is one reason early legal help matters. Tenants harmed at their own complex face these same layered companies, as our post on Tennessee apartment complex negligent security claims explains.

When Is a Security Company Liable for an Attack?

A security company does not become an insurer of everyone on the property. But Tennessee courts recognize that a company that takes on the job of protecting others can be liable when it performs that job carelessly, a principle drawn from Section 324A of the Restatement (Second) of Torts.

Security company liability often turns on questions like:

  • What did the contract require? Patrol frequency, posts to cover, and hours of coverage
  • What were the post orders? Written instructions for each guard
  • Did guards follow them? Patrol logs and GPS records can show missed rounds
  • Were guards properly licensed and trained? Tennessee regulates security guards through the Department of Commerce and Insurance
  • Did a guard cause the harm directly? Excessive force, improper restraint, or a failure to call for help

At bars and other venues that serve alcohol, Tennessee’s Dallas’s Law requires security guards to complete added training in de-escalation, safe restraint, first aid, and CPR. When guards themselves cause injuries, the analysis shifts, as covered in our post on being injured by a bar bouncer or security guard in Tennessee.

Does the Attacker’s Fault Reduce What the Businesses Owe?

Tennessee allows a jury to compare the fault of a negligent business with the fault of the person who committed the intentional attack. The Tennessee Supreme Court approved that comparison in Turner v. Jordan, 957 S.W.2d 815 (Tenn. 1997).

In practice, this means the defense will try to push as much fault as possible onto the criminal, who often has no money or insurance. A well-built case focuses on what the businesses knew, what they could have done, and how their choices created the opportunity for the attack.

What If the Defendants Blame Each Other?

They often do. The owner points to the manager, the manager points to the security company, and the security company points to the contract. Tennessee Code Section 20-1-119 gives you 90 days after a defendant blames a non-party in its answer to add that party to your lawsuit, even if the one-year deadline has passed.

Indemnity clauses and insurance agreements between these companies affect who pays whom behind the scenes. They do not limit your right to recover from the parties at fault.

Proving each defendant’s role takes records that only exist for a limited time. Our article on how to prove a negligent security case in Tennessee walks through the evidence that matters most.

Negligent Security Liability FAQs

Can I sue if the attacker was never arrested?

Yes. Your civil claim against the property’s owners and operators is separate from any criminal case.

Does a “not responsible for crimes” sign protect the property owner?

Not by itself. A sign does not erase the duty Tennessee law places on businesses to respond to foreseeable dangers.

How long do I have to file a negligent security lawsuit in Tennessee?

Generally, one year from the attack under Tennessee Code Section 28-3-104. If the property is government-owned, shorter procedural requirements may apply.

What if I was attacked by a security guard instead of a stranger?

You may have claims against the guard, the security company that employed them, and the business that hired the company.

Finding Every Company That Left You Unprotected

When a property has a history of crime, someone made a decision not to fix it. Identifying that decision, and the company that made it, is how these cases are won.

The Higgins Firm handles negligent security claims in Nashville and throughout Tennessee. Reach out through our contact page for a free, confidential review. You pay nothing unless we recover money for you.

Author Bio

Jim Higgins, founder of the Higgins Firm, is a seasoned personal injury attorney with deep roots in Nashville, Tennessee. A 4th generation Nashvillian, Jim carries on the legal legacy of his father, a judge for over 30 years. After graduating from the University of Memphis School of Law, Jim’s career began on the other side of the courtroom, defending insurance companies and learning their tactics for minimizing settlements. However, he soon realized his true calling was fighting for the rights of the injured, and for the past several years, he has exclusively represented plaintiffs in personal injury cases.

Since then, his dedication and skill have earned him membership in the prestigious Million Dollar Advocates Forum, an organization limited to attorneys who have secured million and multi-million dollar verdicts and settlements for their clients. Licensed to practice in Tennessee, Kentucky, and Georgia, Jim focuses on personal injury, product liability, medical malpractice, and workers’ compensation cases. His exceptional work has been recognized by his peers, earning him a spot on the Super Lawyers list from 2021 to 2024, a distinction awarded to only a select group of accomplished attorneys in each state.

Google | Linked In | Avvo | State Bar Association